deer-flow/frontend/tests/unit/core/messages/human-input.test.ts
qin-chenghan 1bccc8e20e
feat(frontend): allow chat replies during clarification (#4530)
* feat(frontend): allow chat replies during clarification

* fix(frontend): unlock input polish during clarification

Remove hasOpenHumanInputCard from inputPolishDisabled so the polish
button stays available when a clarification card is open, matching
the composer unlock behavior. Clean up the now-unused useMemo and
import.
2026-07-28 22:19:50 +08:00

574 lines
16 KiB
TypeScript
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters

This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.

import type { Message } from "@langchain/langgraph-sdk";
import { expect, test } from "@rstest/core";
import {
buildHumanInputFormSubmissionValue,
buildHumanInputFormSummary,
buildHumanInputResponseText,
buildInitialHumanInputFormValues,
createHumanInputOptionResponse,
createHumanInputTextResponse,
deriveHumanInputThreadState,
extractHumanInputRequest,
extractHumanInputResponse,
hasOpenHumanInputRequest,
readHumanInputFormValue,
shouldClearPendingHumanInputOnThreadError,
} from "@/core/messages/human-input";
const requestPayload = {
version: 1,
kind: "human_input_request",
source: "ask_clarification",
request_id: "clarification:call-abc",
tool_call_id: "call-abc",
clarification_type: "approach_choice",
question: "Which environment should I deploy to?",
context: "Need the target environment.",
input_mode: "choice_with_other",
options: [
{ id: "option-1", label: "development", value: "development" },
{ id: "option-2", label: "staging", value: "staging" },
],
};
test("extractHumanInputRequest reads a valid tool artifact payload", () => {
const message = {
type: "tool",
name: "ask_clarification",
content: "fallback",
artifact: {
human_input: requestPayload,
},
} as unknown as Message;
expect(extractHumanInputRequest(message)).toEqual(requestPayload);
});
test("extractHumanInputRequest rejects malformed artifacts", () => {
const message = {
type: "tool",
name: "ask_clarification",
content: "fallback",
artifact: {
human_input: {
...requestPayload,
options: [{ id: "option-1", label: "missing value" }],
},
},
} as unknown as Message;
expect(extractHumanInputRequest(message)).toBeNull();
});
test("extractHumanInputResponse reads valid human message metadata", () => {
const response = {
version: 1,
kind: "human_input_response",
source: "ask_clarification",
request_id: "clarification:call-abc",
response_kind: "option",
option_id: "option-2",
value: "staging",
};
const message = {
type: "human",
content: "For your clarification, my answer is: staging",
additional_kwargs: {
hide_from_ui: true,
human_input_response: response,
},
} as unknown as Message;
expect(extractHumanInputResponse(message)).toEqual(response);
});
test("derives answered card state from hidden human input responses", () => {
const response = {
version: 1,
kind: "human_input_response",
source: "ask_clarification",
request_id: "clarification:call-abc",
response_kind: "option",
option_id: "option-2",
value: "staging",
};
const state = deriveHumanInputThreadState([
{
type: "tool",
name: "ask_clarification",
content: "fallback",
artifact: {
human_input: requestPayload,
},
} as unknown as Message,
{
type: "human",
content: "For your clarification, my answer is: staging",
additional_kwargs: {
hide_from_ui: true,
human_input_response: response,
},
} as unknown as Message,
]);
expect(state.answeredResponses.get("clarification:call-abc")).toEqual(
response,
);
expect(state.latestOpenRequestId).toBeNull();
});
test("detects whether a thread has an open human input request", () => {
const requestMessage = {
type: "tool",
name: "ask_clarification",
content: "fallback",
artifact: {
human_input: requestPayload,
},
} as unknown as Message;
const responseMessage = {
type: "human",
content: "For your clarification, my answer is: staging",
additional_kwargs: {
hide_from_ui: true,
human_input_response: {
version: 1,
kind: "human_input_response",
source: "ask_clarification",
request_id: "clarification:call-abc",
response_kind: "option",
option_id: "option-2",
value: "staging",
},
},
} as unknown as Message;
expect(hasOpenHumanInputRequest([requestMessage])).toBe(true);
expect(hasOpenHumanInputRequest([requestMessage, responseMessage])).toBe(
false,
);
});
test("detects new thread errors that should unlock pending human input cards", () => {
const previousError = new Error("old failure");
const currentError = new Error("stream failed");
expect(
shouldClearPendingHumanInputOnThreadError({
currentError,
pendingRequestCount: 1,
previousError: undefined,
}),
).toBe(true);
expect(
shouldClearPendingHumanInputOnThreadError({
currentError,
pendingRequestCount: 0,
previousError: undefined,
}),
).toBe(false);
expect(
shouldClearPendingHumanInputOnThreadError({
currentError: previousError,
pendingRequestCount: 1,
previousError,
}),
).toBe(false);
expect(
shouldClearPendingHumanInputOnThreadError({
currentError: undefined,
pendingRequestCount: 1,
previousError: currentError,
}),
).toBe(false);
});
test("creates option and text responses for a request", () => {
const request = extractHumanInputRequest({
type: "tool",
name: "ask_clarification",
content: "fallback",
artifact: {
human_input: requestPayload,
},
} as unknown as Message);
expect(request).not.toBeNull();
const optionResponse = createHumanInputOptionResponse(
request!,
request!.options![1]!,
);
const textResponse = createHumanInputTextResponse(
request!,
"Use blue-green deployment",
);
expect(optionResponse).toEqual({
version: 1,
kind: "human_input_response",
source: "ask_clarification",
request_id: "clarification:call-abc",
response_kind: "option",
option_id: "option-2",
value: "staging",
});
expect(textResponse).toEqual({
version: 1,
kind: "human_input_response",
source: "ask_clarification",
request_id: "clarification:call-abc",
response_kind: "text",
value: "Use blue-green deployment",
});
expect(buildHumanInputResponseText(request!, optionResponse)).toBe(
'For your clarification "Which environment should I deploy to?", my answer is: staging',
);
});
const formPayload = {
version: 2,
kind: "human_input_request",
source: "ask_clarification",
request_id: "clarification:call-form",
question: "Please provide the expense details.",
input_mode: "form",
fields: [
{ name: "amount", label: "Amount", type: "number", required: true },
{
name: "category",
label: "Category",
type: "select",
required: true,
options: [
{ id: "category-option-1", label: "travel", value: "travel" },
{ id: "category-option-2", label: "meals", value: "meals" },
],
},
{
name: "receipts",
label: "Receipts",
type: "multi_select",
required: false,
options: [
{ id: "receipts-option-1", label: "A-1", value: "A-1" },
{ id: "receipts-option-2", label: "A-2", value: "A-2" },
],
},
{ name: "note", label: "note", type: "textarea", required: false },
],
};
function toolMessage(payload: unknown): Message {
return {
type: "tool",
name: "ask_clarification",
content: "fallback",
artifact: { human_input: payload },
} as unknown as Message;
}
test("parses a v2 form request", () => {
expect(extractHumanInputRequest(toolMessage(formPayload))).toEqual(
formPayload,
);
});
test("rejects a form request without fields", () => {
expect(
extractHumanInputRequest(toolMessage({ ...formPayload, fields: [] })),
).toBeNull();
});
test("rejects a form request with malformed fields", () => {
expect(
extractHumanInputRequest(
toolMessage({
...formPayload,
fields: [{ label: "missing name", type: "text" }],
}),
),
).toBeNull();
expect(
extractHumanInputRequest(
toolMessage({
...formPayload,
fields: [{ name: "amount", label: "Amount", type: "slider" }],
}),
),
).toBeNull();
});
test("rejects unknown protocol versions", () => {
expect(
extractHumanInputRequest(toolMessage({ ...formPayload, version: 3 })),
).toBeNull();
});
test("builds a readable form summary submitted as a v1 text response", () => {
const request = extractHumanInputRequest(toolMessage(formPayload))!;
const values = {
amount: "300",
category: "travel",
receipts: ["A-1", "A-2"],
note: "",
};
const summary = buildHumanInputFormSummary(request, values);
expect(summary).toBe("Amount: 300; Category: travel; Receipts: A-1, A-2");
// Request-side-only protocol scope: form answers reuse the existing v1
// text response — no structured response kind is introduced.
expect(createHumanInputTextResponse(request, summary)).toEqual({
version: 1,
kind: "human_input_response",
source: "ask_clarification",
request_id: "clarification:call-form",
response_kind: "text",
value: "Amount: 300; Category: travel; Receipts: A-1, A-2",
});
});
test("form submission value is collision-free via the JSON block", () => {
const request = extractHumanInputRequest(
toolMessage({
...formPayload,
fields: [
{ name: "a", label: "A", type: "text", required: false },
{ name: "b", label: "B", type: "text", required: false },
],
}),
)!;
const first = buildHumanInputFormSubmissionValue(request, {
a: "x; B: y",
b: "z",
});
const second = buildHumanInputFormSubmissionValue(request, {
a: "x",
b: "y; B: z",
});
expect(first).not.toBe(second);
expect(first).toContain('[values: {"a":"x; B: y","b":"z"}]');
expect(second).toContain('[values: {"a":"x","b":"y; B: z"}]');
// Readable prefix is retained for display.
expect(first.startsWith("A: x; B: y; B: z")).toBe(true);
});
test("rejects select options with empty values or duplicates", () => {
const withOptions = (
options: Array<{ id: string; label: string; value: string }>,
) =>
extractHumanInputRequest(
toolMessage({
...formPayload,
fields: [
{
name: "category",
label: "Category",
type: "select",
required: true,
options,
},
],
}),
);
// Empty option value would crash Radix <SelectItem value="">.
expect(withOptions([{ id: "o1", label: "travel", value: "" }])).toBeNull();
// Duplicate option ids / values.
expect(
withOptions([
{ id: "o1", label: "travel", value: "travel" },
{ id: "o1", label: "meals", value: "meals" },
]),
).toBeNull();
expect(
withOptions([
{ id: "o1", label: "travel", value: "travel" },
{ id: "o2", label: "travel-again", value: "travel" },
]),
).toBeNull();
});
test("rejects duplicate field names and enforces the form/version binding", () => {
expect(
extractHumanInputRequest(
toolMessage({
...formPayload,
fields: [
{ name: "amount", label: "Amount", type: "number", required: true },
{ name: "amount", label: "Again", type: "text", required: false },
],
}),
),
).toBeNull();
// form mode is a v2 construct; a v1 payload carrying it is malformed.
expect(
extractHumanInputRequest(toolMessage({ ...formPayload, version: 1 })),
).toBeNull();
// and v2 without form has no defined meaning yet.
expect(
extractHumanInputRequest(
toolMessage({
...requestPayload,
version: 2,
}),
),
).toBeNull();
});
test("rejects form fields with reserved prototype names", () => {
for (const reserved of ["__proto__", "constructor", "toString"]) {
expect(
extractHumanInputRequest(
toolMessage({
...formPayload,
fields: [
{ name: reserved, label: "Amount", type: "number", required: true },
],
}),
),
).toBeNull();
}
});
test("readHumanInputFormValue ignores inherited prototype properties", () => {
const values: Record<string, string> = { amount: "300" };
expect(readHumanInputFormValue(values, "amount")).toBe("300");
expect(readHumanInputFormValue(values, "toString")).toBeUndefined();
expect(readHumanInputFormValue(values, "constructor")).toBeUndefined();
expect(readHumanInputFormValue(values, "__proto__")).toBeUndefined();
});
test("buildInitialHumanInputFormValues seeds checkbox fields to false", () => {
const request = extractHumanInputRequest(
toolMessage({
...formPayload,
fields: [
{ name: "amount", label: "Amount", type: "number", required: true },
{ name: "urgent", label: "Urgent", type: "checkbox", required: false },
],
}),
)!;
expect(buildInitialHumanInputFormValues(request.fields ?? [])).toEqual({
urgent: false,
});
});
test("summary renders an untouched checkbox as an explicit no", () => {
const request = extractHumanInputRequest(
toolMessage({
...formPayload,
fields: [
{ name: "amount", label: "Amount", type: "number", required: true },
{ name: "urgent", label: "Urgent", type: "checkbox", required: false },
],
}),
)!;
const values = {
amount: "300",
...buildInitialHumanInputFormValues(request.fields ?? []),
};
expect(buildHumanInputFormSummary(request, values)).toBe(
"Amount: 300; Urgent: no",
);
});
test("a plain reply closes only the latest unanswered request", () => {
const olderPayload = {
...formPayload,
request_id: "clarification:call-older",
};
const state = deriveHumanInputThreadState([
toolMessage(olderPayload),
toolMessage(formPayload),
{
type: "human",
content: "answer to the second question",
} as unknown as Message,
]);
// The reply answers the request the user was looking at (the latest); the
// older decision must not be silently swallowed with the same text.
expect(state.answeredResponses.get("clarification:call-form")?.value).toBe(
"answer to the second question",
);
expect(state.answeredResponses.has("clarification:call-older")).toBe(false);
expect(state.latestOpenRequestId).toBe("clarification:call-older");
});
test("a visible plain human reply bypasses and closes an open request", () => {
// The normal composer deliberately sends no structured response metadata.
// Treating its message as the answer lets users bypass the form and also
// preserves compatibility with old frontends that render v2 as plain text.
const messages = [
toolMessage(formPayload),
{
type: "human",
content: "金额 300类别差旅",
} as unknown as Message,
];
const state = deriveHumanInputThreadState(messages);
expect(state.latestOpenRequestId).toBeNull();
const answered = state.answeredResponses.get("clarification:call-form");
expect(answered?.response_kind).toBe("text");
expect(answered?.value).toBe("金额 300类别差旅");
expect(hasOpenHumanInputRequest([toolMessage(formPayload)])).toBe(true);
expect(hasOpenHumanInputRequest(messages)).toBe(false);
});
test("a visible human message before the request does not close it", () => {
const state = deriveHumanInputThreadState([
{
type: "human",
content: "帮我提交报销",
} as unknown as Message,
toolMessage(formPayload),
]);
expect(state.latestOpenRequestId).toBe("clarification:call-form");
});
test("hidden non-response messages do not close an open request", () => {
const state = deriveHumanInputThreadState([
toolMessage(formPayload),
{
type: "human",
content: "internal context",
additional_kwargs: { hide_from_ui: true },
} as unknown as Message,
]);
expect(state.latestOpenRequestId).toBe("clarification:call-form");
});
test("derives answered state for a form request answered by text", () => {
const response = {
version: 1,
kind: "human_input_response",
source: "ask_clarification",
request_id: "clarification:call-form",
response_kind: "text",
value: "Amount: 300",
};
const state = deriveHumanInputThreadState([
toolMessage(formPayload),
{
type: "human",
content: "answer",
additional_kwargs: { hide_from_ui: true, human_input_response: response },
} as unknown as Message,
]);
expect(state.answeredResponses.get("clarification:call-form")).toEqual(
response,
);
expect(state.latestOpenRequestId).toBeNull();
});