deer-flow/backend/tests/test_extension_api_contracts.py
Nan Gao c542185a7f
feat(extensions): add gateway contribution points and packaged extension management (#4780)
* feat(extensions): add gateway services and routers

* feat(extensions): add standalone reference extension

* fix(extensions): harden contributed gateway routes

* docs(extensions): document gateway contribution points

* feat(extensions): add operator CLI for packaged extension management

Add `deerflow extensions install/list/enable/disable/remove` plus the root
`make extension-*` wrappers, backed by an `ExtensionManager` that owns one
transaction over backend/pyproject.toml, backend/uv.lock, the managed source
snapshot, the uv environment, and the `plugins:` block in config.yaml.

Install accepts a package requirement, a public HTTPS Git URL, or a local
directory. Local directories are copied to backend/extensions/sources/ as
deployable snapshots rather than editable installs, and the root .dockerignore
re-includes that tree so snapshots reach the backend builder. Remote sources are
HTTPS-only; SSH Git, file:// and local wheels are rejected because the stock
Docker builder cannot reproduce them.

Because environment configuration can still resolve a plain package name to a
local wheel (a UV_FIND_LINKS wheelhouse, say), every uv add/remove is followed
by an audit of the new lock: any local reference the stock image build cannot
reproduce rolls back the whole transaction. A config carrying duplicate
top-level `plugins:` keys is rejected outright rather than managed against one
block while the Gateway reads another.

Dependency synchronization now has one lock authority. The `extensions`
dependency group joins [tool.uv].default-groups, every startup path syncs the
same lock with --locked and launches with --no-sync, and the Docker images move
to uv 0.11.1 for the --no-workspace boundary the manager needs.

Loader gains `enabled`, `name` and `package` fields so a disabled extension is
skipped before resolution and import.

Co-authored-by: Codex <codex@openai.com>

* fix(extensions): stop the managed plugins rewrite from destroying config

Two data-safety defects in the managed `plugins:` block writer.

The "next top-level key" boundary was a regex matching only
`[A-Za-z_][A-Za-z0-9_-]*` or a quoted key. `AppConfig` is `extra="allow"`, so a
config may legally carry any top-level key, and a key the pattern cannot
recognize did not fail loudly — it read as "no next section", and the rewrite
replaced that neighbour and its entire subtree with the managed block. `my.key`,
`2fa`, `$schema`, `my key` and non-ASCII keys were all silently deleted by a
plain `extension-enable`/`disable`. Both boundaries now come from the YAML
parser's node marks, so key shape is irrelevant.

The file-final branch never consulted the trailing-comment scan the has-next-key
branch used, so any comment below the block was dropped. Since the manager
appends `plugins:` at end of file, that is the steady-state shape for most
installs: an operator note below the block was destroyed on the next toggle.

Separately, every managed install wrote `required: true` while the loader
defaults to false. That turned any later load failure — broken wheel, missing
native library, deleted snapshot — into a Gateway startup abort recoverable only
with shell access. New records are now written `required: false`, with an
explicit `install --required` opt-in; adopting an existing hand-written record
still preserves the operator's own choice.

* fix(extensions): harden the manager transaction and correct its docs

Follow-up hardening on the extension package manager.

Security posture, which the docs already claimed:
- Scrub `UV_PYTHON`, `UV_INSECURE_HOST`, `UV_CONSTRAINT` and
  `UV_NO_BUILD_ISOLATION` from the controlled uv environment. `UV_PYTHON` swaps
  the interpreter that the entry-point probe then imports and calls, and every
  later `uv run --no-sync` startup uses; `UV_INSECURE_HOST` removes the TLS
  validation the HTTPS-only source rule depends on. Neither is an index, proxy,
  cache or credential-provider setting, so neither was covered by the carve-out.
- Recognize run-together and all-caps secret query parameters (`accesstoken`,
  `ACCESSTOKEN`, `key`, `pw`, `sas`, `code`). The camel-case splitter only fires
  on case transitions, so only the separated spellings were caught. Short
  generic words stay boundary-anchored, so `?keyword=` remains installable.
- Validate the config before running any uv command. `uv add`/`uv sync` execute
  the package's build backend, so a config the manager could never write to must
  fail before that code runs rather than afterwards through rollback.

Transaction integrity:
- Run the second dependency-file restore from a `finally`. The recovery sync
  runs without `--locked` when the checkout had no lock, so uv writes one while
  resolving; if that sync then failed, the restore was skipped and the operator
  kept a lock file they never had. A failing recovery sync now also reports the
  original failure instead of replacing it.
- Skip the recovery sync on cancellation. Answering Ctrl-C with a full
  dependency resolve invites a second interrupt that escapes the handler and
  strands the checkout mid-transaction; the declarations are already restored
  and the next locked startup sync reconciles the environment.
- Retry a non-blocking lock on Windows instead of using `msvcrt.LK_LOCK`, which
  gives up after ~10s — far shorter than a real `uv add` plus `uv sync`, so
  contention surfaced as `Permission denied` rather than serializing.
- Locate the entry-point probe's JSON payload instead of parsing stdout's first
  line, so a `sitecustomize`/`.pth` banner cannot roll back a good install.
- Warn when the lock records a loopback source. `127.0.0.1` inside the image
  builder is a different machine, but unlike an environment-driven wheelhouse
  resolution this is a source the operator typed deliberately, so it is reported
  rather than rolled back. Private-network indexes are untouched: a builder on
  that network can reach them.

Docs: the blanket claim that failed operations restore the config file was
wrong — the conflict branches deliberately preserve a concurrent external edit
and leave `remove` deactivated. Document that, the `required: false` default,
the config preflight, the interrupt behaviour, and where the plugins-block
boundaries come from.

* test(gateway): pin the request-path projection agreement

`get_request_route_path()` imports the private
`starlette._utils.get_route_path` so the auth and CSRF predicates classify
the exact string Starlette's router matches on. Its requirement is not
"strip root_path correctly" but "return what the dispatcher is matching",
so delegating to the router's own implementation keeps the two in lockstep
by construction. Keep the private import rather than vendoring a copy: an
import that disappears fails loudly at startup, while a stale copy diverges
silently at a security boundary.

Cover the property directly instead of the mechanism, so the tests survive
a future reimplementation:

- projection edge cases, including the segment-boundary guard that keeps
  root_path="/api" from slicing "/apifoo/models" into a string the router
  would never match
- agreement with the router under nested mounts
- the two bypasses these predicates exist to prevent: a protected route
  mounted under the "/health" public prefix must still 401, and a POST
  mounted under "/api/webhooks" must still require a CSRF token

Both are verified to fail when the projection is reverted to
`request.url.path` (9/13 red) and when a plausible vendored copy omits the
boundary guard (the 2 boundary cases red).

Declare starlette as a bounded direct dependency so a bump — which is
security-relevant here — shows up in review rather than arriving silently
through FastAPI.

* ci: pin uv to the version production ships

ExtensionManager is not a consumer of uv the build tool -- it is a program
whose whole job is driving `uv` as a subprocess, depending on its CLI
behavior (`--no-workspace`, `--no-sync`, what `uv add` writes into
`[dependency-groups] extensions`) and on the `uv.lock` serialization format.
uv is closer to a runtime dependency with a contract than to incidental
tooling.

backend/Dockerfile pins that binary to 0.11.1, but all eight
astral-sh/setup-uv steps installed whatever was latest at run time, so CI
exercised the manager against a uv that is not the uv production runs. The
sharpest failure that allows: a newer uv bumps uv.lock's `revision`, CI
stays green because the same uv reads back what it wrote, and the pinned uv
in the production image cannot read the committed lock. `uv lock --check`
is version-sensitive for the same reason -- it verifies the lock is what
*this* uv would produce, and two versions can emit equivalent but
non-identical output.

Pin every step to 0.11.1 and lift the one lingering setup-uv@v3 to v7 so
the steps share input and caching behavior.

Pinning alone drifts apart again on the next bump, so add a constraint test
in the style of test_compose_default_bind_host.py: the Dockerfile's
UV_IMAGE tag is the single source of truth, and both compose defaults plus
every setup-uv step must match it. Verified to fail when a pin drifts, when
a step omits `version`, and -- the real scenario -- when the Dockerfile is
bumped alone, which lights up the workflows and both compose files at once.

* fix(gateway): state the extension route auth limit and abort a failed dev sync

Two scoped review follow-ups.

README: contributed routers cannot enter the host's reserved public prefixes,
which makes every extension endpoint session-authenticated -- there is no way
to expose an unauthenticated route. The rejection rule was documented but its
consequence was not, so inbound provider webhooks and public status endpoints
read as merely undocumented rather than out of scope for this release.

docker/dev-entrypoint.sh: the self-heal retry reuses `--locked`, so it repairs
a corrupt .venv but never a lock that disagrees with pyproject.toml. `set -e`
already stopped the script there -- uvicorn was not being started against a
stale environment -- but it exited on a bare uv exit code with no indication of
what to do. Abort explicitly with the cause and the fix.

Tests slice the sync block out of the real script and run it against a stub uv,
so they exercise the shipped code rather than a copy of it (/app/backend only
exists inside the container). They cover the success path, the retry that
recovers, the abort, and the guidance. Verified against the pre-fix script:
only the guidance case goes red, confirming the abort itself was already
correct.

* fix(extensions): point Git SSH shorthand at the HTTPS correction

Git's SCP-like shorthand carries no URL scheme, so `git+git@host:org/repo.git`
reached the scheme rules looking like a bare path and was rejected with
"local path references are not deployable; pass a local directory so DeerFlow
can snapshot it". The operator asked for a remote source, so that guidance
points at the wrong fix. Detect the shorthand ahead of the scheme rules and
report the public-HTTPS correction instead.

The bare `git@host:org/repo.git` spelling took a different wrong turn: packaging
parses it as a direct reference named `git`, leaving `host:org/repo.git`, whose
`host` reads as a URL scheme and produced the generic HTTPS message. Both
spellings now share one message, as does the PEP 508 named form.

* docs: keep the root extension summary within its new budget

#4799 split the depth out of the module guides and added a size gate; the root
file's job is now orientation, and this branch had pushed it 192 bytes past the
soft limit. The manager transaction, source rules, and lock discipline are
already stated in full in the extensions guide, so the root keeps the one-line
orientation and points there instead of restating them.

---------

Co-authored-by: Codex <codex@openai.com>
2026-08-13 23:55:30 +08:00

321 lines
11 KiB
Python

"""Tests for the extension contract surface.
The contracts carry two compatibility promises that are easy to break by
accident and impossible to catch at runtime later: every Protocol method has a
default implementation, and every optional dataclass field has a default. Both
are asserted here.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import asyncio
import dataclasses
import importlib.resources
import inspect
import pytest
from deerflow_extension_api import (
API_VERSION,
AgentBuildContext,
AgentScope,
ExtensionData,
ExtensionInstall,
ExtensionRegistry,
ExtensionRuntimeDeps,
ExtensionService,
HostPolicySnapshot,
MiddlewareContributor,
MiddlewarePlacement,
Placement,
SystemModelCallObserver,
SystemModelRequest,
SystemModelResult,
SystemOperationKind,
TaskInfo,
TaskLifecycleContributor,
TaskOutcome,
extension,
)
from deerflow_extension_api.runtime_bridge import (
EXTENSION_TASK_STORE_KEY,
task_store_from_runtime,
)
def test_placement_members_cover_both_axes():
assert Placement.MODEL_LOGICAL.value == "model_logical"
assert Placement.MODEL_PHYSICAL.value == "model_physical"
assert Placement.TOOL_VISIBLE.value == "tool_visible"
assert Placement.TOOL_RAW.value == "tool_raw"
assert Placement.STANDARD.value == "standard"
def test_agent_scope_both_is_union():
assert AgentScope.BOTH == AgentScope.LEAD | AgentScope.SUBAGENT
assert AgentScope.LEAD in AgentScope.BOTH
def test_middleware_placement_defaults():
p = MiddlewarePlacement(middleware=object(), placement=Placement.STANDARD)
assert p.scope is AgentScope.BOTH
assert p.order == 0
@pytest.mark.parametrize(
"cls",
[
HostPolicySnapshot,
ExtensionRuntimeDeps,
AgentBuildContext,
TaskInfo,
SystemModelRequest,
SystemModelResult,
MiddlewarePlacement,
],
)
def test_every_dataclass_is_frozen(cls):
assert dataclasses.is_dataclass(cls)
assert cls.__dataclass_params__.frozen, f"{cls.__name__} must be frozen"
@pytest.mark.parametrize(
"cls",
[HostPolicySnapshot, ExtensionRuntimeDeps, TaskInfo, SystemModelRequest, SystemModelResult],
)
def test_additive_dataclasses_are_constructible_with_required_fields_only(cls):
"""Fields added later must carry defaults, or old extensions break on upgrade.
HostPolicySnapshot and the two system-call snapshots are host-constructed
and fully optional. TaskInfo has a required identity core and optional
remainder. AgentBuildContext gets its own dedicated test below because its
scope is legitimately required.
"""
if cls is TaskInfo:
info = cls(task_id="t", run_id="r", thread_id="th", kind="lead")
assert info.parent_task_id is None
assert info.agent_name is None
assert info.resumed is False
else:
assert cls() is not None
def test_agent_build_context_optional_fields_keep_their_defaults():
"""AgentBuildContext has one required field (scope); the rest must default.
Unlike the fully-optional dataclasses above, scope is legitimately
required, so this is not folded into the parametrized test above — it
would misrepresent the required/optional split this suite is meant to
document.
"""
ctx = AgentBuildContext(scope=AgentScope.LEAD)
assert ctx.agent_name is None
assert ctx.model_name is None
assert isinstance(ctx.policy, HostPolicySnapshot)
@pytest.mark.parametrize(
"protocol",
[
ExtensionRegistry,
ExtensionService,
MiddlewareContributor,
TaskLifecycleContributor,
SystemModelCallObserver,
],
)
def test_every_protocol_method_has_a_default_implementation(protocol):
"""Adding a method to a Protocol is only additive when it has a default.
Without this, shipping a new contract method breaks every already-released
extension that does not implement it.
"""
checked = 0
for name, member in vars(protocol).items():
if name.startswith("_") or not inspect.isfunction(member):
continue
checked += 1
body = inspect.getsource(member).split("\n", 1)[1]
assert "return" in body, f"{protocol.__name__}.{name} has no default implementation. Adding a contract method is only additive when it returns a default; otherwise every already-released extension breaks on upgrade."
assert checked > 0, f"{protocol.__name__} declared no methods to check"
def test_contributor_defaults_return_empty():
class _Bare:
pass
bare = _Bare()
assert MiddlewareContributor.contribute_middlewares(bare, ExtensionData("app"), AgentBuildContext(scope=AgentScope.LEAD)) == ()
def test_task_lifecycle_contract_is_public_and_defaults_to_noop():
class _Bare:
pass
app_store = ExtensionData("app")
task_store = ExtensionData("task-1")
info = TaskInfo(
task_id="task-1",
run_id="run-1",
thread_id="thread-1",
kind="lead",
)
assert TaskOutcome.COMPLETED.value == "completed"
assert asyncio.run(TaskLifecycleContributor.on_task_start(_Bare(), app_store, task_store, info)) is None
assert asyncio.run(TaskLifecycleContributor.on_task_stop(_Bare(), app_store, task_store, info, TaskOutcome.COMPLETED)) is None
def test_system_model_observer_contract_reports_success_and_failure_shapes():
class _Bare:
pass
app_store = ExtensionData("app")
task_store = ExtensionData("task-1")
request = SystemModelRequest(messages=("prompt",), model_name="system-model")
success = SystemModelResult(response="answer", duration_ms=1.5)
failure = SystemModelResult(error=RuntimeError("provider failed"), duration_ms=2.0)
assert SystemOperationKind.GOAL.value == "goal"
assert asyncio.run(SystemModelCallObserver.on_system_model_call(_Bare(), app_store, task_store, SystemOperationKind.GOAL, request, success)) is None
assert asyncio.run(SystemModelCallObserver.on_system_model_call(_Bare(), app_store, task_store, SystemOperationKind.GOAL, request, failure)) is None
def test_system_model_request_normalizes_messages_into_an_immutable_sequence():
"""``messages`` is a snapshot of a message sequence, never a per-character view.
Title and summarization pass a single prompt string, so a bare ``str`` must not
reach observers as a ``Sequence`` whose items are characters. A live ``list`` from
a call site must also be copied: the snapshot is documented as read-only, and the
caller keeps mutating its own list after the observation is dispatched.
"""
assert SystemModelRequest(messages="one prompt").messages == ("one prompt",)
live: list[str] = ["first"]
request = SystemModelRequest(messages=live)
live.append("second")
assert request.messages == ("first",)
assert SystemModelRequest().messages == ()
assert SystemModelRequest(messages=("already", "a", "tuple")).messages == ("already", "a", "tuple")
def test_gateway_contribution_points_are_part_of_the_public_surface():
import deerflow_extension_api
for name in (
"ExtensionRuntimeDeps",
"ExtensionService",
):
assert name in deerflow_extension_api.__all__
assert hasattr(deerflow_extension_api, name)
assert callable(ExtensionRegistry.service)
assert callable(ExtensionRegistry.routers)
assert not hasattr(deerflow_extension_api, "RouterContributor")
def test_task_store_from_runtime_reads_the_host_key():
class _Runtime:
def __init__(self, context):
self.context = context
store = ExtensionData("task-1")
assert task_store_from_runtime(_Runtime({EXTENSION_TASK_STORE_KEY: store})) is store
def test_task_store_from_runtime_returns_none_on_missing_or_wrong_shape():
class _Runtime:
def __init__(self, context):
self.context = context
assert task_store_from_runtime(None) is None
assert task_store_from_runtime(_Runtime({})) is None
assert task_store_from_runtime(_Runtime("not-a-mapping")) is None
assert task_store_from_runtime(_Runtime({EXTENSION_TASK_STORE_KEY: "wrong type"})) is None
def test_extension_decorator_stamps_api_requirement():
@extension(api="0.1", name="demo")
def install(registry, config):
return None
assert install.__deerflow_api__ == "0.1"
assert install.__deerflow_name__ == "demo"
def test_task_outcome_members():
assert {outcome.value for outcome in TaskOutcome} == {"completed", "aborted", "failed"}
def test_system_operation_kind_members():
assert {kind.value for kind in SystemOperationKind} == {"goal", "memory", "title", "summarization"}
def test_registry_and_install_alias_are_part_of_the_public_surface():
"""Independent extensions annotate install(registry, config) against the
contract package alone — importing the host's concrete registry would pin
them to the harness release cadence and advertise host-only machinery."""
import typing
import deerflow_extension_api
assert "ExtensionRegistry" in deerflow_extension_api.__all__
assert "ExtensionInstall" in deerflow_extension_api.__all__
parameters, return_type = typing.get_args(ExtensionInstall)
assert parameters[0] is ExtensionRegistry, "install()'s first argument must be the public registry contract"
def test_distribution_marks_the_contract_package_as_typed():
marker = importlib.resources.files("deerflow_extension_api").joinpath("py.typed")
assert marker.is_file()
def test_contract_package_keeps_runtime_dependencies_empty():
import tomllib
from pathlib import Path
pyproject = Path(__file__).parent.parent / "packages" / "extension-api" / "pyproject.toml"
assert tomllib.loads(pyproject.read_text())["project"]["dependencies"] == []
def test_harness_pins_the_contract_package_exactly():
"""The version contract (extension-system design): the host pins the
contract package exactly, extensions use ranges. A range here would let an
older harness resolve a newer 1.x contract package — API_VERSION would
then come from the upgraded package and newer extensions would look
supported against a host whose registry/placements/hook pipeline still
implements the older contract. The pin makes pip reject that skew at
install time."""
import tomllib
from importlib.metadata import version
from pathlib import Path
from packaging.requirements import Requirement
pyproject = Path(__file__).parent.parent / "packages" / "harness" / "pyproject.toml"
dependencies = tomllib.loads(pyproject.read_text())["project"]["dependencies"]
requirement = next(Requirement(dep) for dep in dependencies if Requirement(dep).name == "deerflow-extension-api")
expected = f"=={version('deerflow-extension-api')}"
assert str(requirement.specifier) == expected, f"the host must pin deerflow-extension-api exactly ({expected}); a range lets pip resolve a contract newer than the host implements"
def test_runtime_api_version_matches_the_installed_contract_package():
"""Every additive contract slice bumps both gates together."""
from importlib.metadata import version
assert API_VERSION == "0.1.2"
assert API_VERSION == version("deerflow-extension-api")
def test_extension_service_contract_is_public_and_defaults_to_noop():
class _Bare:
pass
deps = ExtensionRuntimeDeps()
assert deps.app_store is None
assert deps.session_factory is None
assert asyncio.run(ExtensionService.start(_Bare(), deps)) is None
assert asyncio.run(ExtensionService.stop(_Bare())) is None