Hyeonsang Cho 9146bfa03d
feature(gateway): issue request trace ids unconditionally (#5119)
* refactor(gateway): issue request trace ids unconditionally

The request trace id was gated behind logging.enhance.enabled at every
entry point, so downstream code had to keep asking whether one existed:
a header-provenance flag in its own ContextVar, a precedence resolver,
and three-level carrier fallbacks at each consumer.

Bind one unconditionally instead. TraceMiddleware covers Gateway HTTP;
ensure_trace_context covers the entry points that never touch ASGI --
scheduled occurrences, MCP task notification runs, IM channel messages,
and the embedded client -- each scoped to one unit of work so a
long-lived worker task cannot leak one occurrence's id into the next.
The ContextVar becomes the only source; the response header, runtime
context, run metadata and log records are derived outputs.

Consumers now use ensure_trace_id() or resolve_trace_id(*carriers) and
drop their presence guards. Removed: resolve_deerflow_trace_id, the
header-provenance flag and its three helpers, set/reset_current_trace_id,
is_trace_correlation_enabled and its gateway alias.

BREAKING CHANGE: every Gateway HTTP response now carries X-Trace-Id and
it cannot be turned off; logging.enhance.enabled controls log output
only. Installations on the default enabled: false will start seeing the
header. No config keys were added or removed.

* fix(gateway): stop persisting a caller-supplied trace id on the run record

body.metadata forks two ways: through build_run_config into the live run
config, which the run worker restamps, and through create_or_reject into
the run record that the runs API echoes verbatim. Only the first was
covered, so a client sending metadata.deerflow_trace_id made the most
durable and most visible surface of a run disagree with the X-Trace-Id
and the log lines the same request produced -- a correlation id that
does not match the logs is worse than none.

Stamp the server-issued id once at the trust boundary so both forks
receive it, preserving the caller's own metadata keys. Close the same
gap on config.context, which reaches the runtime context by a separate
path: _build_runtime_context no longer merges server-owned keys from the
caller, and _install_runtime_context assigns rather than setdefaults.

A thread's metadata is no longer seeded with the run-scoped id of
whichever run created it -- one thread spans many runs and as many
trace ids.

Found by driving a real run through the Gateway and reading the run back
from the runs API; every unit test built its metadata by hand and so
could not see it.

* fix(gateway): expose X-Trace-Id to split-origin browser clients

X-Trace-Id is not on the CORS safelist, so a browser client served from
a separate origin could not read it -- and those are exactly the clients
that cannot read the Gateway's logs either, leaving them with nothing to
quote in a bug report. Same-origin nginx deployments were unaffected,
which is why this stayed hidden.

Add it to CORS_EXPOSED_HEADERS beside Content-Location, referencing
TRACE_ID_HEADER rather than repeating the literal.

* fix(gateway): keep X-Trace-Id on unhandled-exception 500s

Starlette's ServerErrorMiddleware sits outside every user middleware and
emits unhandled-exception 500s through the raw send, so those responses
never pass TraceMiddleware's header-writing wrapper. The 500 for a server
bug is exactly the response a user most needs to correlate with a log line,
and it was the one response that shipped without the id.

TraceMiddleware now tracks whether http.response.start has been sent. On an
exception with no response started it emits its own plain 500 carrying the
header, then re-raises: the outer ServerErrorMiddleware sees the response
already started and only re-raises too, so the server's exception logging is
untouched. An exception mid-stream keeps propagating unchanged — a second
response start cannot be sent, and the already-written header stands.

The trace id is printable ASCII by construction (normalize_trace_id /
generate_trace_id), which is what makes the raw latin-1 header encoding
safe.

* fix(gateway): strip the forged trace id from the persisted request echo

The run-record fix stopped a forged metadata.deerflow_trace_id on the
authoritative metadata surface, but the raw request echo still carried one:
create_or_reject persists body.config verbatim as runs.kwargs_json, which
the runs API serves back. A client posting config.context.deerflow_trace_id
therefore still got its forged value stored and echoed on one API surface
while the header, logs, run metadata, and checkpoint all carried the real
id — the id is ignored as input there, so echoing it back only manufactures
disagreement.

Two changes close it. redact_config_secrets — already the shared scrub for
that echo, applied at admission and again at serve time, so historical
records are covered too — now also drops deerflow_trace_id from
config.metadata and config.context. And build_run_config now merges run
metadata onto a copy of the caller's config["metadata"] instead of updating
it in place: the nested values of the request config are reference copies,
so the in-place merge was writing the server-stamped key through into
body.config, contaminating the "what the client sent" record before it was
persisted (and incidentally masking the forged-value echo on the metadata
container).

The regression test posts a forged id through body.metadata,
config.metadata, and config.context at once and reads the kwargs echo back
off the run record, failing if either leak returns.

* docs(harness): record the trace-echo scrub, 500 fallback, and accepted retry divergence

The trace section of the harness AGENTS.md now covers the two fixes that
close the derived-output rule (the kwargs-echo scrub in
redact_config_secrets plus build_run_config's copy merge, and
TraceMiddleware's own 500 for unhandled exceptions), and CHANGELOG gains
their Fixed entries.

It also writes down the one accepted divergence: a crash-recovered
scheduled launch reuses the durable run through its idempotency key, and
start_run returns early on idempotency_reused without restamping — so the
run record keeps the first attempt's deerflow_trace_id while the retry's
own log lines carry the freshly minted id of its ensure_trace_context
binding. The divergence is confined to the crash-recovery window and is
accepted rather than fixed: restamping on reuse would rewrite a persisted
record for a run that already exists, which is worse than two ids that each
correlate their own attempt's logs. Written down so the next reader of the
scheduler recovery path does not diagnose it as a bug.

* docs(config): align the logging.enhance schema note with the unconditional trace id

The config-module AGENTS.md still described logging.enhance as the gate for
the Gateway X-Trace-Id header and Langfuse deerflow_trace_id. That model is
gone: ids are issued unconditionally and this block decides log output only.
Left as-is, the stale wording invites an agent to "restore" a header gate it
believes was lost. Reworded to match the sibling AGENTS.md files and
config.example.yaml, with a pointer to the Request Trace Context section
that owns the full model.

* docs(changelog): link the trace entries to #5119

The five new entries pointed at the ([#XXXX]) placeholder with no reference
definition, rendering as literal text instead of a link — and RELEASING.md
step 2 relies on those references when the section becomes release notes.
All five now point at #5119, with the definition appended to the reference
block.

* refactor(harness): rename _stream_without_trace_context to _stream_turn

The name asserted the opposite of what the method now does. It was accurate
while logging.enhance.enabled could route stream() around the trace scope;
with the gate gone it is the only stream implementation left, and it binds
the id itself via ensure_trace_id(). Private, so the rename touches only the
definition and the one stream() call site.

* docs(harness): fit the trace-context guidance inside the AGENTS.md chain budget

The expanded Request Trace Context section pushed the effective AGENTS.md
chain for agents/middlewares to 99,815 bytes, past the 98,304 hard limit
scripts/check_agent_guidance.py enforces in CI (AG002). Compressed the
section from 7,359 to 4592 bytes with no facts removed: the entry-point
table, the derived-output rule and its enforcement points, the accepted
scheduled-retry divergence, the two resolution helpers, the stream()
binding rationale, the log-output-only gate, the CORS listing, the 500
fallback, and the test map all remain.

Sized against the merge, not just the branch: current main grew the same
chain by ~724 bytes, so the check was verified on the merged tree as well
(97,772 bytes; branch tree 97,048).

* fix(gateway): declare content-length on the fallback 500

The pre-response 500 declared content-type but no content-length, leaving
the framing to the ASGI server: chunked on HTTP/1.1, close-delimited on
HTTP/1.0 — the one wire difference from the ServerErrorMiddleware response
it replaces, which sends content-length: 21. The explicit header keeps the
fallback byte-identical to what clients saw before.

* docs(readme): drop the trace-correlation condition from the translations

The zh/ja/fr/ru Langfuse sections still said metadata.deerflow_trace_id
matches X-Trace-Id "when request trace correlation is enabled". The id now
always matches and that condition no longer exists, so each bullet states
the unconditional match and that logging.enhance.enabled only controls
whether the id is printed into logs — the one piece of the feature a user
can still configure.

* test(gateway): pin TraceMiddleware wiring through create_app()

Every X-Trace-Id test exercised a hand-built four-route app, so the real
stack's add_middleware(TraceMiddleware) line was pinned by nothing: deleting
it — or short-circuiting above it — passed CI while silently dropping both
the response header and the ambient id the run-record stamp and enhanced log
records derive from. One case now drives /health through create_app() and
asserts the inbound id round-trips; mutation-checked by removing the wiring
line, which fails exactly this test.

* docs(gateway): note the fallback 500 is CORS-opaque

The pre-response 500 is emitted outside CORSMiddleware — the exception has
already unwound past it — so it carries no Access-Control-Allow-Origin and
a split-origin browser client cannot read the id on this one response,
unchanged from the ServerErrorMiddleware 500 it replaces. Documented on the
class and in the CHANGELOG entry rather than fixed: replicating the origin
allowlist outside CORSMiddleware would let the two policies drift.

* fix(harness): keep abandoned-stream cleanup inside the trace binding

stream() binds the turn's id around each next(inner) and resets it before
yielding, but the finally's inner.close() ran after that binding was gone.
Abandoning the stream therefore drove the inner LangGraph generator's
GeneratorExit/finally path with no trace id — or an unrelated ambient one
from whichever context ran the close — so cancellation and finalization
logs and callbacks did not correlate with the turn they belong to.

inner.close() is now wrapped in a local bind/reset of the same turn id. The
token is set and reset in the same frame, never across a yield, so the
per-step cross-context safety is preserved even when GC closes the
generator from another Context — pinned by the existing copy_context close
test, which now exercises this path. The regression test records the id
from the inner generator's finally and fails without the binding.

* test(harness): teach the worker-trace fake about RunManager.cleanup

Upstream #5112 (bound gateway memory after terminal runs) added a
run_manager.cleanup(run_id) call to run_agent's finalization, so the
merge-commit CI run failed all five worker-trace-binding tests with
AttributeError on this PR's _FakeRunManager. The fake gains the same no-op
shape as its other methods.

* docs(gateway): bring the gateway AGENTS.md back under its soft budget

Upstream #5092 grew backend/app/gateway/AGENTS.md to 40,966 bytes, 6 over
the 40,960 soft budget that
test_agent_guidance_check.py::test_repository_guidance_stays_below_soft_budgets_and_avoids_doc_indexes
enforces — its Unit Tests run on main was cancelled by push concurrency, so
main is currently red on that test and every PR merge-run inherits the
failure. Two whitespace/wording trims in the row #5092 touched (a doubled
space, and "its configured `context_window`" → "its `context_window`")
bring the file to 40,953 with no content change.

---------

Co-authored-by: Willem Jiang <willem.jiang@gmail.com>
2026-09-01 16:49:39 +08:00

140 lines
8.8 KiB
Python

"""Single source of truth for the config hot-reload boundary.
Bytedance/deer-flow issue #3144: gateway request dependencies resolve
``AppConfig`` through ``get_app_config()`` on every request, so per-run
fields take effect on the next message without restarting the gateway.
The fields listed in this module are the **infrastructure** subset that
the gateway captures once at startup — engines, singletons, IM clients,
the logging handler — and that therefore require a process restart to
change at runtime.
The registry covers two kinds of entries:
- ``AppConfig`` fields and explicitly registered nested fields (``database``, ``checkpointer``,
``run_events``, ``stream_bridge``, ``sandbox``, ``log_level``). For
these, :func:`format_field_description` produces the standardised
``"startup-only: ..."`` prefix that the matching Pydantic
``Field(description=...)`` carries, so the boundary surfaces in IDE
hover next to the field itself.
- Top-level ``config.yaml`` sections that are not part of the
``AppConfig`` schema (``channels``). These cannot be standardised at
the schema level, so the registry is their only canonical location.
Any future "needs restart" scanner — operator tooling, lint hooks, doc
generators — should drive off this registry rather than re-parsing
prose.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
from collections.abc import Iterator
#: The standardised prefix every restart-required field description starts
#: with. ``test_reload_boundary`` enforces both directions: registered
#: fields must use this prefix in the schema, and any schema field using
#: this prefix must be in the registry.
STARTUP_ONLY_PREFIX = "startup-only:"
#: Restart-required field paths mapped to the human-readable reason.
#:
#: The reason text is what surfaces in ``Field(description=...)``, so it
#: must explain *what* code captures the snapshot — not just that the
#: field is restart-required — so an operator changing the value knows
#: which subsystem to restart.
STARTUP_ONLY_FIELDS: dict[str, str] = {
"plugins": ("load_extensions() runs once during create_app() and the process-wide middleware registry is not rebuilt on config.yaml edits; adding, removing or reconfiguring a plugin requires a restart."),
"database": ("init_engine_from_config() runs once during langgraph_runtime() startup; the SQLAlchemy engine holds the connection pool and is not rebuilt on config.yaml edits."),
"checkpointer": ("make_checkpointer() binds the persistent checkpointer once at startup, including SQLite WAL / busy_timeout settings."),
"run_events": ("make_run_event_store() picks the memory- vs SQL-backed implementation at startup and is frozen onto app.state.run_events_config to stay paired with the underlying event store."),
"agent_storage": ("langgraph_runtime() validates agent_storage.backend against database.backend once at startup, and the db backend's synchronous SQLAlchemy engine is process-cached on first use; switching backend needs a restart."),
"stream_bridge": ("make_stream_bridge() constructs the stream-bridge singleton once during startup."),
"sandbox": ("get_sandbox_provider() caches the provider singleton (``_default_sandbox_provider``); a different ``sandbox.use`` class path only takes effect on next process start."),
"skills.container_path": (
"AioSandboxProvider and E2BSandboxProvider normalize and capture the skills mount root when their provider singleton starts; "
"sandbox identity, mounts, remote metadata, and skill synchronization must keep using that one root until the Gateway restarts."
),
"log_level": (
"apply_logging_level() runs only during app.py startup; it sets the deerflow/app logger levels and may lower root handler thresholds so configured messages can propagate. A freshly reloaded AppConfig does not retrigger it."
),
"logging": (
"configure_logging() runs only during app.py startup; it installs/removes the trace-context filter and the enhanced formatter on root handlers, "
"and a freshly reloaded AppConfig does not retrigger it, so a runtime edit to logging.enhance.* needs a Gateway restart. Only log output is "
"affected: trace ids are issued unconditionally and always returned in the X-Trace-Id response header, whatever this setting says."
),
# Not part of the AppConfig Pydantic schema — channel credentials are
# consumed directly by ``start_channel_service()`` once at lifespan
# startup and the live channel clients are not rebuilt on
# config.yaml edits.
"channels": ("start_channel_service() is invoked once during startup; the live IM channel clients (Feishu, Slack, Telegram, DingTalk) are not rebuilt when channels.* changes."),
"channel_connections": (
"start_channel_service() wires the connection repository and channel workers once at startup, and the channel-connections router caches the merged provider config on app.state; channel_connections.* edits need a restart."
),
"scheduler": (
"ScheduledTaskService is constructed and started once during Gateway lifespan startup; enabled, poll_interval_seconds, lease_seconds, "
"max_concurrent_runs, queue_timeout_seconds, and multi_instance are captured into the service instance and the background poller task is not rebuilt on config.yaml edits. "
"Changing multi-instance recovery prerequisites or lease behavior requires restarting every Gateway Pod together. "
"scheduler.recursion_limit is not captured there: launch_scheduled_thread_run reads it from get_app_config() on each dispatch, so a YAML edit applies to the next scheduled run without a Gateway restart."
),
"mcp_tasks": (
"McpTaskService is constructed and started once during Gateway lifespan startup; enabled, poll_interval_seconds, lease_seconds, "
"and max_concurrent_polls are captured into the service instance and the background poller task is not rebuilt on config.yaml edits."
),
"subagent_runtime": ("the shared native-subagent admission controller and isolated execution loop are configured once during Gateway lifespan startup; changing process slots, queue policy, or queue bounds requires a restart."),
"subagent_batches": ("the durable subagent batch service is constructed and started once during Gateway lifespan startup; scheduler limits, leases, and recovery behavior are captured by that service instance."),
"run_ownership": (
"RunOwnershipConfig is captured once into RunManager at langgraph_runtime() startup; the lease heartbeat background task is created and "
"started there, and heartbeat_enabled / lease_seconds / grace_seconds are not re-read on config.yaml edits."
),
"dedupe_storage": (
"make_inbound_dedupe_store() resolves the inbound dedupe store once when ChannelService is constructed at startup; the store "
"(in-process memory or shared Postgres) is captured onto ChannelManager and is not rebuilt on config.yaml edits."
),
}
def iter_startup_only_field_paths() -> Iterator[str]:
"""Yield every registered restart-required field path."""
return iter(STARTUP_ONLY_FIELDS)
def is_startup_only_field(field_path: str) -> bool:
"""Return ``True`` when *field_path* is registered as restart-required.
Most entries are top-level paths (``"database"``, ``"sandbox"`` etc.).
A nested path is registered only when one leaf has a different reload
boundary from the rest of its section, such as ``skills.container_path``.
"""
return field_path in STARTUP_ONLY_FIELDS
def format_field_description(field_path: str, *, field_doc: str | None = None) -> str:
"""Build the standardised description for a registered field.
Used inside ``AppConfig`` ``Field(description=...)`` so the hover
text in IDEs matches the registry and the drift tests can pin one
side against the other.
Args:
field_path: A registered field path (e.g. ``"log_level"`` or
``"skills.container_path"``).
field_doc: Optional human-facing description for the field itself
(allowed values, semantics, etc.). When supplied, it is
appended after the ``startup-only:`` marker block separated by
a blank line so IDE hover shows both the restart-required
reason *and* the field's normal documentation. Composition
keeps the marker as the leading token machine-readable tooling
pivots on while restoring the prose that ``Field(description=)``
used to carry before the registry took over.
Raises:
KeyError: when *field_path* is not registered. This is deliberate
— silently returning a placeholder would let a typo bypass
the drift coverage.
"""
reason = STARTUP_ONLY_FIELDS[field_path]
header = f"{STARTUP_ONLY_PREFIX} {reason}"
if field_doc is None:
return header
return f"{header}\n\n{field_doc.strip()}"