Four findings from @willem-bd on #4401:
- FeedbackDialog stays mounted across messages, so selected tags and the
comment survived an ESC/click-outside dismiss and pre-filled the next
thumbs-down. Reset on every close path via a wrapped onOpenChange.
- Neither the dialog's handleSubmit nor handleDialogSubmit caught a failed
enrichment PUT, so a rejection went unhandled and the user got no signal.
Catch in the dialog (where the rejection lands), toast, and keep the input
for a retry.
- rate_run awaited the RunLookup port before Feedback.create validated the
rating, contradicting its own "before any I/O happens" docstring: an
invalid rating on an unknown run surfaced as RunNotFoundError. Validate
first, restoring the legacy router's 400-before-404 ordering. The service
test now uses an unknown run id so it actually pins that order.
- InMemoryFeedbackRepository moved out of test_feedback.py into
tests/feedback_fakes.py (with FakeRunLookup) so two test modules share it
without one importing the other; conftest states the tests-dir sys.path
dependency explicitly, which also makes it work under
--import-mode=importlib.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
